SimpliSafe vs Ring: Which Home Security System to Choose?

Both SimpliSafe and Ring have their pros and cons. Here are the pros and cons to help you weigh your options based on your priorities—ease of installation, budget or high-tech features.

SimpliSafe Pros and Cons

Pros:

1. Easy DIY Installation: SimpliSafe is designed for easy self-installation, making it accessible for users who prefer a hassle-free setup.
2. No Contracts Required: Users can choose month-to-month monitoring plans without being locked into long-term contracts, providing flexibility.
3. Variety of Equipment: SimpliSafe offers a wide range of equipment, including alarms, cameras, and environmental sensors.
4. Customizable Plans: Users can tailor their security packages to fit their specific needs, choosing only the devices they require.
5. Affordable Pricing: SimpliSafe's pricing is generally lower than many competitors, offering good value for money.

Cons:

1. Limited Smart Home Integration: While SimpliSafe does offer some smart home compatibility, it is less extensive than Ring’s ecosystem.
2. No Professional Monitoring in All Areas: Availability of professional monitoring services can vary based on location.
3. Basic Mobile App: The mobile app may lack some advanced features and functionalities compared to competitors.
4. Less Focus on Outdoor Security Cameras: While they offer security cameras, their outdoor camera options are not as extensive as Ring’s.

Ring Pros and Cons

Pros:

1. Comprehensive Security Options: Ring specializes in video doorbells and outdoor cameras, providing extensive options for outdoor security.
2. Advanced Smart Home Integration: The Ring system easily integrates with various smart home devices and voice assistants like Alexa and Google Assistant.
3. User-Friendly Mobile App: The Ring app is intuitive and provides features such as live streaming and two-way communication.
4. Subscription Options: Ring offers flexible subscription plans, including basic free access to recorded videos for specific devices.
5. Community Features: Ring's Neighbors app allows users to stay informed about local crime and security issues, enhancing community safety.

Cons:

1. Professional Monitoring Costs: Ring's professional monitoring services can be more expensive than those offered by competitors.
2. Limited No-Contract Options: While Ring does offer some flexibility, users may still find themselves needing to commit to longer-term contracts.
3. Privacy Concerns: Some users have raised concerns about data privacy and sharing with law enforcement.
4. Installation Challenges: Although installation is mostly straightforward, some users may find wiring and setup for certain devices complex.

Features and Background of SimpliSafe and Ring

Both SimpliSafe and Ring have unique features and smart camera offerings that cater to different security needs. Here’s a closer look at each brand.

SimpliSafe

SimpliSafe is a home security company founded in 2006 to provide affordable and accessible home security. They specialize in no-frills DIY home security systems that are easy to install and don’t require professional help. SimpliSafe has a no-contract model, users can choose monitoring plans that fit their needs without long-term commitments.

Key Features and Offerings

• Home Security Systems: SimpliSafe has customizable security systems with various components including entry sensors, motion detectors, and cameras.
• Environmental Monitoring: In addition to security features, SimpliSafe has environmental sensors for smoke, carbon monoxide, and water leaks.
• Mobile Access: Users can monitor their homes through a mobile app, get alerts, and control their security system remotely.

Ring

Founded in 2013, Ring made its mark in the home security industry with its innovative Ring doorbell camera, which revolutionized how homeowners monitored their front doors. Now, Ring offers a comprehensive suite of home security systems.

Key Features and Offerings:

• Video Doorbells: Industry-leading doorbell cameras.
• Outdoor Cameras: Wireless outdoor cameras with motion detection.
• Ring Alarm Security Kit: Includes a base station, motion sensor, and more for whole-home protection.
• Smart Home Integration: Works seamlessly with Google Assistant, Alexa, and other smart devices.
• Ring App: Full control of your system remotely, with live video feeds, two-way communication, and notifications.

SimpliSafe vs Ring: Key Comparisons

Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s get into the nitty-gritty of the comparisons between the SimpliSafe System and the Ring Alarm System. We’ll look at installation and setup, equipment, monitoring options, mobile app, pricing, and customer service.

Installation and Setup

SimpliSafe Installation Process: SimpliSafe prides itself as a DIY home security system, often requiring no tools or professional help. Everything is designed to be easy to install from the ground up. The system includes devices like key fobs and motion detectors that are easy to set up.

Ring Installation Process: Ring, while also a DIY installation system, offers more complex devices like outdoor cameras and video doorbells, which may require more advanced setup. However, Ring Alarm also has a professional installation option if needed.

Winner: When it comes to ease of installation, SimpliSafe has the edge by allowing you to build your own system from burglary sensors to hazard sensors. Ring devices offer more flexibility with professional installation options, but this can add extra costs and complexity.

Equipment and Devices

SimpliSafe Equipment Offerings:

SimpliSafe provides a variety of equipment options, including:

• Entry Sensors: An entry sensor detects when doors or windows are opened.
• Glass Break Sensors: A glass break sensor picks up the sound of smashed windows.
• Motion Detectors: Monitor movement within designated areas.
• Cameras: Outdoor/indoor camera for surveillance.
• Environmental Sensors: Smoke, carbon monoxide, and water leak detectors.

Ring Equipment Offerings:

Ring focuses heavily on video security, offering:

• Video Doorbells: A video doorbell allows users to see and communicate with visitors.
• Security Cameras: Outdoor and indoor Ring camera models for continuous surveillance.
• Alarm Systems: Comprehensive alarm systems with smart locks and multiple sensors.

Winner: Both brands provide a good variety of devices, but Ring's focus on video surveillance gives it an edge for outdoor security. SimpliSafe offers more comprehensive options for environmental monitoring.

Monitoring Options

SimpliSafe Monitoring Plans: SimpliSafe has four monitoring plans: Pro Plus, Pro, Core (formerly Fast Protect), Standard, and Self Monitoring with Camera Recordings. The plans start at $9.99/month for self-monitoring which allows 30-day recording for up to 10 cameras and $79.99/month for Pro Plus which includes 24/7 Active Guard Outdoor Protection.

Ring Monitoring Plans: Ring offers professional monitoring through its Ring Protect Plans. The Ring Protect Basic plan starts at $4.99/month or $49.99/year for one camera. The highest tier plan starts at $20/month or $200/year and includes 24/7 professional monitoring, video recording, cloud storage, phone support, cellular backup, and extended warranties on all devices.

Winner SimpliSafe’s monitoring plans are slightly more budget-friendly than Ring’s.

Mobile App and User Interface

SimpliSafe Mobile App: The SimpliSafe app is simple and easy to use. You can arm and disarm the system, receive push notifications, and monitor cameras.

Ring Mobile App: Ring’s app is one of the most advanced in the home security industry. It has live video feeds, two-way communication, custom motion detection zones, and integrations with smart home devices. You can also control multiple cameras and devices with the app.

Winner: While SimpliSafe’s app is easy to use, Ring’s app is more comprehensive and customizable. If you want more control and flexibility, Ring’s app is the way to go.

Pricing and Packages

SimpliSafe Pricing Structure and Packages: SimpliSafe has packages from basic to full systems with prices starting at $99 for a basic camera. Monitoring plans start at $9.99/month for up to 10 cameras.

Ring Pricing Structure and Packages: Ring’s packages also vary with devices from as low as $59 for basic to over $500 for full systems. Monitoring subscriptions start at $4.99/month for basic coverage for one camera.

Winner: SimpliSafe is often viewed as more affordable for equipment, while Ring offers better value for users needing extensive video surveillance.

Customer Service and Support

SimpliSafe Customer Service: SimpliSafe has good customer service with phone and email support. Users report positive experiences with quick response times and helpful representatives.

Ring Customer Service: Ring has good customer support with phone, email and chat support. But some users have complained about the time it takes to resolve issues especially with more complex installs or advanced devices.

Winner: Both companies get mixed reviews for customer support but SimpliSafe scores slightly higher overall. Ring because of its wider range of products has more varying user experiences.

Similarities Between SimpliSafe and Ring

Despite their differences, SimpliSafe and Ring share some key similarities, particularly in their use of wireless technology, smart home compatibility, and customizable security solutions.

Wireless Technology

Both SimpliSafe and Ring use wireless technology for easy installation, eliminating the need for complex wiring or professional installation in most cases. A wireless outdoor camera offers greater flexibility and are easier to install, making them ideal for renters and homeowners alike.

Home Automation Compatibility

Both systems are compatible with smart home devices, though Ring offers deeper integration, particularly with Amazon Alexa. SimpliSafe also supports Google Assistant and Alexa, but its smart home capabilities are more limited in comparison. While Ring doesn't offer native compatibility with Google Home, there are still some workarounds you can try.

Customizable Security Solutions

Both systems offer customizable security setups. Users can choose from various devices and sensors to create a security system tailored to their specific needs. Whether you want basic protection or a full suite of devices, both companies provide flexible options.

How SimpliSafe and Ring Differ?

While SimpliSafe and Ring have some similarities, they differ in key areas such as their focus on video doorbells, DIY security system vs professional installation, and their offerings in environmental sensors.

Video Doorbells

Ring has a clear advantage when it comes to video doorbells. It offers a wide range of high-quality doorbells with features like HD video, two-way communication, and advanced motion detection. SimpliSafe, on the other hand, offers fewer options in this category.

DIY vs Professional Monitoring

SimpliSafe security system focuses heavily on DIY installation and monitoring, making it perfect for users who want to avoid professional installation fees and self monitor. Ring offers both DIY and professional installation options, giving users more flexibility.

Environmental Sensors

SimpliSafe excels in its range of environmental sensors, offering devices for smoke, carbon monoxide, and water leak detection. Ring focuses more on security cameras and alarm systems, making it a better choice for users primarily interested in surveillance.

Which Security System is Better for You?

Scenario-Based Recommendations

• Best for Budget-Conscious Users: SimpliSafe is the better option for those who want to build their own systems from the ground up. It is an affordable, contract-free security system with an option for free self monitoring.
• Best for Tech-Savvy Users: Ring is ideal for users who want a high-tech security system with advanced features, including smart home integration and customizable alerts.
• Best for Users Needing Advanced Features: If you're looking for advanced video doorbells, outdoor cameras, and a comprehensive mobile app access, Ring is the better choice.

Final Verdict

Both Ring and SimpliSafe offer reliable home security solutions, but your choice will depend on your specific needs and budget. SimpliSafe is the best choice for users seeking a simple, affordable, and easy-to-use system with no long-term contracts. Ring, on the other hand, is better suited for tech-savvy users who want advanced features, smart home integration, and a wide range of camera options.

FAQ

Is SimpliSafe as good as Ring?

Yes, SimpliSafe and Ring offer strong home security solutions, but SimpliSafe excels in comprehensive monitoring options, while Ring is known for its user-friendly video doorbells and cameras.

What is the downside of SimpliSafe?

The main downside of SimpliSafe is its reliance on cellular connectivity, which may be less reliable in remote areas compared to some internet-based systems.

Is there a system better than Ring?

While Ring is popular for video security, systems like Arlo or Nest may offer superior features, such as advanced camera quality and broader smart home integration.

What is better than SimpliSafe?

Systems like ADT or Vivint provide professional installation and advanced features, making them potentially better options for users seeking comprehensive home security solutions.